I've had the medium tote for a few months now and use it several times a week for small shopping runs, gym/pool, around town. It's sturdy, waterproof inside and out (and easy to clean), and sits flat. I do wish the straps were just a bit longer to make carrying it over the shoulder easier. Also, I wish it had an inside key loop or lanyard. Overall, a good tote that I expect to last.
The best thing about my new medium Hunter's Tote Bag is that it's designed for real-world use. It's got a flat bottom, so it will stand up when placed on a flat surface. And that flat bottom makes it easy to pack and unpack it. It is lined with a waterproof coating. The material it's made of is substantial and rugged, and should withstand years of use. In this size, I can carry in it a book, jacket or vest, an umbrella, and a couple of bottles of water...and it will fit into my small locker at work. I can't find a single negative thing to say about this item, and I would give it more than 5 stars if possible. :-)