Very happy with this item. Better than surplus if you can even find them. Warm. Comfy. On sizing, I'm a stout so I went with an XL. Fits the shoulders but sleeves are a little long.
For the price, I was worried that this would be a thin-ish, mid-quality item. When it came in the mail, however, I was pleasantly surprised and this sweater punches WELL above its weight. Nice trim fit, love the roll cuffs and the fact that the elbows are reinforced is great for me. I am VERY pleased with my purchase...I will probably be back shortly to get a couple more in other colors!!! Do note, however that the green one is actually brown as others have noted.
I really dig the commando sweater and may get another one. I got a lots a comments on it and asked where I got it. I think its Keith Richards cool and that is as high as one can get .