I would like to rate this sweater higher. A few years ago I bought the black version, in XL, and it is one of my favorite sweaters of all time. It is well fitted, comfortable but not baggy at all. This one, in XL as well, fits like an undergarment or base layer, verging on too tight.
High quality item but very tight around the forearms and made with scratchy material. I haven't owned one before so maybe this is normal, but I wouldn't have bought it if I'd known how it fit and felt.