Super warm, soft. I'm tall and thin, and the large is long enough, but way too wide. I had to take them in. I'll have to stick with men's smalls in the future.
Me too. But rather than return it, I've decided to take it to the tailor/dry cleaners and ask them to put in snaps for me. It's perfect in every other way (well, I never intended to use the back flap, so I can't comment there). It's very warm, comfy fabric, but it's not something I can even wear until I get the snaps. It would (will be) perfect for breast-feeding with the snaps to keep the rest SHUT.