I like how well-made these shoes are and the insole gives my feet some nice support. I do wish the heel area was a little different, as my heels slide in them just a bit with cotton socks on. The toe box area is also more narrow than my beloved LLBean boat mocs.
Having the shoes stretched a little solved the toe box problem. Even the cobbler commented that the shoes were made well.
OK, admittedly, I have been "thinking about" ordering these since 6th grade...which was a VERY LONG time ago...but I finally got a gift card that made it impossible to put off the purchase any longer. These are great shoes with comfy insoles. They hold up well in wet or mucky weather, and I couldn't be happier with them. One little thing...I believe that now they are made abroad (of American materials?) I do wish they were still USA-made.
After reading all of these great reviews I was really excited to get these shoes. However I was very disapointed once I received. The quality is not there for the amount of money paid. They look cheap, they are not comfortable and I will be sending them back.