I like these shirts a lot, but with my relatively long upper torso they are too short, especially after washing, to easily tuck in to slacks and keep them there.
This mock turtleneck fit my husband well and is comfortable, BUT, this shirt and others we have purchased shrink in length in both the arms and the body. We have only washed it twice, so far, and the wrist is already getting further up his arm. I wash it in cold water and dry on delicate, cool setting, but still get shrinkage! Why does this keep happening? We purchased this shirt, and others to replace ones that had shrunk over time and this one starts shrinking after only 2 washings. I am disappointed. Otherwise the fit and comfort are great.
I ordered 5 (3-white, 1 navy, 1 grey) to use as a winter base layer. I am 6'2", 195lbs with a 16.5" neck and 35" sleeve. The store clerks recommended that I purchase the tall size large. After one wearing, the white and navy necks stretched out and lost shape, the grey has a bit of elastic in the neck so it continued to fit snugly. I laundered them in cold water and used the lowest dryer setting. After 2 washings, they have all shrunk excessively. I will be returning all 5 to the store and will not purchase this item again.
I have had this shirt for about one and a half months. I am 6 feet tall. I find the sleeves in this shirt too short for comfort. Maybe shorter person could find them ok. Sorry!