The Pros: Feels great. Good look. I feel like these are a very good quality.
The Con: Not sized as reported.
The Gist: My shoe size is between a 14 and 15 in men's sizes, so when I saw the size chart for these report 13 to 15 I was very happy to give them a shot. I like the way that they look and the feel of the fabric, but they are not true sized. I would recommend these to most people, but probably not to anyone with a shoe size higher than 13. The outermost curve of the sock heel does not reach the outermost curve of my heel, which I would have expected from a sock sized up to a 15. Instead, the sock is a solid two to two and a half inches short of that.
In short, if your shoe size is at or below a men's 13 then I would recommend these, think about jumping up a size. Men's shoe sizes over 13 should think about another pair of socks.
I purchased one navy colored set, wore for a week then ordered another two sets. Great quality, super warm, no itchy wool, great value. Super Warm and Cozy this Winter....great for wearing around the house too ;)
After two previous orders for this item and being unsatisfied with the sizing (particularly after washing) I bought the XL for my size 10 feet. After washing and drying these the fit is perfect. Previous sizing left the product way too short in both length and height. Usable, but not comfortable. The only reason for the average rating is the size issue. The construction is good, the product wears well, and it is quite comfortable in the right size. If you're a 10 or above order the XL for an acceptable fit. The many comments about being undersized are accurate!
