I have several carefree unshrinkable shirts (LS/SS/Henley) and am delighted with them all. They are soft and hold up very well with no shrinking or fading. For the price they are a bargain.
I ordered 2 of these shirts after having bought one at an LL Bean store. The store-bought shirt was great -- good fit, washed well, looked good. It was kind of quality I have come to expect from LL Bean. The shirts ordered from the online site must have come from a different manufacturer. The neck was so large, it no longer fit like a T-shirt. Unfortunately, I had already washed one before wearing it, so it went to Goodwill. The other was returned. Not a good experience.