I've had this jacket since Christmas and am fairly pleased with it. It is true that the liner pulls out slightly when putting it on over thicker clothes and the sleeves of what you're wearing can bunch up a little but I think it's being overblown slightly. I've learned tricks to putting it on when wearing sweaters, etc and it isn't that bad. I had another 3-in-1 from a different manufacturer and this is far superior. I also had a parka from someone else. After getting this I gave both away. It's the only cold-weather coat I own and need anymore. My only suggenstion would be to have closable pockets on the inside of the inner lining. I'm not crazy about putting my phone in the open inner pocket although I haven't had any issies with it so far. Just wish there was a pocket with a zipper, button or velcro. Overall though I would get this jacket again.
Very good for any temperature. I would recommend ordering the next larger size than you normally wear. The sizes fit tighter than other jackets I have bought.
Seems reasonably well-made, but it's just uncomfortable. The sleeves of the zip-out liner are unlined and held in only by a couple of elastic loops, so if you're wearing anything with more texture than an oxford shirt under it, you won't be able to put the coat on without the sleeves catching on it. I don't try to wear sweaters or flannel shirts under this, too hard to put it on. The front doesn't hang right - the right side wants to flip back and show the liner, so you can't wear it with the zipper undone. It's pretty warm once you get it put on and pull all the wrinkles out of your sleeves, but there's no way to keep from wadding up whatever you're wearing under it unless you put the liner on first, then the coat over it and zip the liner in while you're wearing it. I would return this today but it's been too long, doubt they'd take it back.
I bought this jecket because I really liked all the 3 in 1 concept. I wore it the day after it arrived. It was a total disappointment. When I put the jacket on, the inner sleeve extended beyond the outer sleeve, I had to pull it back. When I took the jacket off, the sleeves from the inner jacket came out of the outer sleeves. The jacket was warm but it is too much work to wear.
