I love the jacket. it looks great with the green fleece inside liner and the blue exterior shell. It's certainly warm. My only complaint is when you put the jacket on, the inside fleece liner (wrist cuff) "bunches up" with the outside shell wrist cuff. It seems the inside liner wrist cuff is secured with only 1 button causing excessive movement and "bunchung" of the wrist cuff. The addition of 1 more button would solve the problem.
Jacket feels to be one to one and half inches shorter than the one I bought 5 years ago and still wear. Jacket is missing the zipper pocket on the shell at the left breast side. This pocket was very useful and it exists in my current 3-1 jacket and my current full lengh great coat. Mistake to remove.