I own the longest length in black, the 3/4 length in light blue, and now I own the shortest length in spruce green. I love them all! very warm, not too bulky..the winters in PA can be challenging; however, with these coats I stay warm and comfortable. I love them.
To be honest, it hasn't gotten cold enough to wear this jacket yet. I chose to rate it based on my first impression. This is a WOW. The fit was fantastic! No need to size up to accommodate a sweater or other winter garments like I've found in the department stores. The sleeves were long enough which is I problem I've had in the past. The jacket is well made and it didn't take long at all to overheat when trying it on, so I'm guessing it'll be just fine this winter! I'm pleasantly surprised and very happy I took the chance.