The pair of slippers was not the same size---cleary one shorter than the other by about 1/2 inch; stitching also very different on each slipper and also off by about 1/2 inch. This is not the first time we have had this same issue with LLBean footwear.
I've been wearing leather soled scuffs of another brand for 15 years and the soles literally show no sign of wear, but the shearling liner is finally wearing thin. Since these have held up so well, I knew I wanted something with leather soles and shearling liner as a replacement and was having a difficult time finding it.
I had buyer's remorse shortly after ordering these moccasins at such a hefty price tag, but the minute I slipped them on, I knew that it was money well spent! Other slippers with synthetic liners tend to smell awful and have to be pitched long before they wear out. I know that will not be the case with these beauties that are well constructed of quality materials. I truly anticipate wearing them for the next 20 years or more.
I typically wear a 7 1/2, sometimes an 8, and I like my shoes to feel snug on my feet. I ordered a 7 based on several others saying they run large, and I'm glad I did. They are just right, plenty of room in length and quite snug in width, but not uncomfortably so. I'm certain they will stretch out and conform to my feet as others have described.
I bought a pair of these moccasins in the Outlet Store for $20 back in the early 80's. The sole looks almost brand new. I have waterproofed them several times, and wear them out and about, not just around the house (that means on concrete sidewalks and to the store).
I have had the stiching repaired only one time on the top left side.
I think they will last another 10 years until the stiching totally comes apart.
Best value for the money I ever spent.
P.S. I live in Florida now and still have a L.L. Bean down parka from the 80's too. I wore that in Maine for about 8 years before I moved here. Now I only wear it once or twice a year when I come up North to visit.