I ordered the Warthog 6'x5' rug in brown. It's not winter here yet in MN (thankfully), so I don't know how well it holds the water and dirt yet. I do want to comment though that the rug looks great and the size and color are true. I read a lot of the other reviews before buying this and people talked about how it looked like the rug was patched together or the color didn't look right. I didn't have either of those problems. It does however have a smell to it because of the rubber bottom, so I'm hoping that goes away.
I ordered a 6'x5' mat, I got a 5'10''x5' mat. Two inches isn't much, but I really could use it. Also, as others have noted, there is a line going down the mat where it was stitched together, but it can only be seen when looking very, very closely. Despite all this, I like the mat and would order it again.
We bought this mat six months ago for our back door entryway in tan, 6’x5’, in preparation for our new Brittany pup and for our daughter and her friends to come into the house with their wet, snowy boots & bibs and also summer time water play. We haven’t had an abundance of water on the mat to test the ridged border, but it has definitely helped to keep our hardwood floor clean during everyday life. The mat isn’t very attractive, but it is fairly easy to vacuum clean, and it stays in place. It is a bit flawed, however, which is disappointing, especially considering the price: at about a foot from one side, the mat appears to have been pieced together and the squares were not lined up properly, so a 1’x6’ area of the design is off from the rest of the mat. It isn’t terribly obvious, but it is noticeable. We kept the mat because we needed it immediately. It would be nice if the perfect-size mat was available in another design and more colors. We bought the khaki outdoor mat, leaf design, and it’s very nice.