I ordered a heather chocolate and a solid cream and like both very much. I ordered a medium and found the neck size to be just right for me. The heather choc is butter soft, much softer than the solid cream.
I ordered this in a medium, which fit fine except it was tight around my throat. The neck was loose enough but I could barely get if off over my head -- and I have a small head! I wanted to keep it because I liked it otherwise but will return it. I also order a large in a solid color with a scrunch neck and had the same problem. I'm reordering my usual mock turntlenecK!
I reeeeaaaalllly love this little turtleneck. Super-soft fabric and the lighter weight is perfect to wear under other layers. Nice on it's own, too, in our Santa Cruz winters. The heather-y hazelnut color is yummy. This is the first turtleneck I reach for when the weather starts to cool down. Looks great with my wide-leg LL Bean jeans.
I purchased this Scrunchneck Tee to go with a pair of LLB corduroy pants. The color of the shirt is great, and it is definitely ultrasoft and comfortable. I would have preferred this to be made of a slightly heavier material. It still fills my needs.